Published on Sep. 8, 2020 by Steven Vance
Updated on Sep. 10, 2020
I asked some people who want the city to let them build a backyard home or other accessory dwelling unit to speak at the Chicago zoning committee meeting on Tuesday, 9/8/20, even though the ADU ordinance was not on the agenda. I said last week that it was unlikely that the ADU ordinance, which was introduced in May 2020, would be heard at the committee meeting. A revision ordinance is expected, but it hasn’t been introduced yet.
Carmin Ballou has already talked to three architects, including Monica Chadha, about the design feasibility of building a backyard home. However, the proposed ordinance would require that Carmin obtain a “special use” from the Zoning Board of Appeals, a costly and uncertain endeavor, because the ordinance treats RS-1 and RS-2 zoning districts differently, and her house happens to be in an RS-2 zoning district — excluded in the proposed ordinance along with over 162,000 other properties. Carmin permitted me to reprint her speech to the committee.
Hi, my name is Carmin Ballou and I’m here to speak in favor of the passage of an ADU ordinance, but in particular to request that RS-1 and RS-2 houses be included in that ordinance. I want to thank many of you present today for working on this issue, but as a 47th Ward resident, I also want to thank Matt Martin for his advocacy on it.
Our multi-generational household has been following the ordinance closely because first, we support the expansion of affordable housing in our neighborhood. Our neighborhood has grown increasingly expensive and puts access to the quality neighborhood school and the safety the neighborhood provides out of reach for many. We support the addition of affordable housing units in many forms, but particularly today through the introduction of an ADU ordinance to expand access to affordable units.
Second, because we are interested in the option for our family of three generations. My parents moved from Nebraska three years ago and while they initially explored getting their own unit, we value our time and like living in close proximity to each other, including sharing meals to assisting with piano lessons to playing numerous board games. We want to stay together. We value the experience that multi-generational living provides, but an ADU would provide more privacy and independence to my parents than they currently have.
However, as the proposed ordinance stands, we will not be able to build a garage apartment. Whether intentional or a fluke of historical zoning, a few streets including ours are zoned RS-2 and so would be excluded while other newer construction around us has been zoned RS-3. I’m speaking today to give you one example of why that exclusion would be a mistake. We live in a 100-year-old house and are committed to keeping its historical look. But around us, bungalow after bungalow has been torn down and replaced by large footprint houses. By excluding RS-2, this continues to encourage the demolition of the smaller home to be replaced with a larger square footage unit. By building a garage apartment instead, we keep the historical look of our house, but simply expand our footprint off the alley.
And these twin goals of expanding affordable housing and encouraging multi-generational living were goals that we supported before the outbreak of COVID. But now we’ve gone from two people (my parents) home during the day with freedom and quiet, we now have two working parents, a 3rd grader and a 7th grader enrolled in CPS’ remote learning and two helpful grandparents, all home fighting for space and quiet. While I realize it is a privilege to be able to explore this option, requiring a special use permit — with its additional cost and hassle without a guarantee of approval — will likely put that option out of reach. Please pass the ADU ordinance quickly, but please consider the inclusion of RS-1 and RS-2 units in it.
Thank you
Commentary: I want an ADU, but the RS-2 exclusion would prevent me from building one was originally published in Chicago Cityscape on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.
The new Chicago Park District headquarters is under construction
The 2022 scavenger sale results are in
What’s up in the West Loop: Cranes
ADU permits trickling in spring 2022
Chicago’s first two-unit modular house is constructed — more are on the way
Apply for this new property tax incentive by March 31
Efficiently find and prospect Scavenger Sale properties
The next Scavenger Sale starts in February 2022
Data Equity Cohort at the midpoint: recent progress + future improvements
Podcast: Spotting Chicago development trends and opportunities
Cityscape’s Top 12 stories in 2021
Chicago hits 21 ADU permits in 2021
This architecture firm is doing the most ADU projects right now
Bickerdike plans to expand service area, to develop more eTOD
Where the new construction hotspots in Chicago are
Six ADU permits have been issued since May 2021
Where the new state-enacted property tax incentive applies
Cityscape has the maps you need to locate where new ARO rules apply
What does the 2020 Census data tell us about Chicago and Chicagoans?
Chicago wants to sell four parking lots it owns on the North Side
Chicago might allow cannabis dispensaries in more zoning districts
The first three Obama Presidential Center permits were issued
Cityscape receives grant to launch a “Data Equity Cohort”
See if you have a new electoral district in 2022 with adopted redistricted maps
110 property owners have told City Hall they intend to build an ADU
New maps, data, and filters were added for affordable housing developers and advocates
Find historical imagery for Cook County addresses
See Carmin’s future backyard ADU
A new “off-site” ARO townhouse development opens on the West Side
Chicago developers are constructing bigger wood residential buildings due to changes in the code
Use new Cityscape tools to grow your ADU business
Cityscape maps updated to reflect new Illinois legislators
Outside the Loop radio shows talks about backyard houses with Chicago Cityscape
Cityscape’s Top 12 stories of 2020
Chicago’s ADU ordinance explained in a 4-minute video
Chicago will allow ADUs starting in May — Read our FAQ
City Council to review revised ADU ordinance to apply in pilot areas only
A better ADU rule has the potential to build lower-cost houses on vacant land
Take a tour: Chicago’s first modular house is move-in ready
Chicago prepares a deconversion ban near the 606
Chicago readies two North Lawndale sites for sale and redevelopment
Mapping investments in INVEST South/West areas
Is COVID-19 affecting Chicago building permits?
Commentary: I want an ADU, but the RS-2 exclusion would prevent me from building one [you're reading this one]
Filling a zoned “Pedestrian Street” gap will bring TOD benefits to more blocks
Get a look at new basement ADUs in Bronzeville + 2 other projects
The modular “starter house” in Back of the Yards was assembled
Ask Cityscape: Could I build two ADUs at my house?
Here’s what ADU supporters told City Council at the first hearing
Chicago’s ADU ordinance gets a hearing date
Chicago’s ADU ordinance was introduced — see what you could build
New zoning rules adopted last week
Ordinance would change approval rules for certain industrial uses
Prefab “starter home” is under construction, destined for a vacant lot in Back of the Yards
See what’s in the development pipeline
New data: How many Airbnbs are in your neighborhood
Ask your alder to support ADUs
Three North Side “Pedestrian Streets” are being combined
Make informed decisions by using your own boundaries
Make informed decisions by mixing your data with Cityscape’s
Metra should add a new station in Humboldt Park
Legalize ADUs across Illinois, lawmaker’s bill says
The one Chicago guidebook you need to read this year
Work in industrial real estate? Chicago Cityscape does, too
Let’s keep ADUs in the 2020 news
Cityscape Pro is now available for 1, 2, and 3 month terms
Downtown land that Chicago owns is up for sale again — this time thru a sustainable design…
Recreational pot sales start in 13 days
Two South Side community hubs are moving forward with investment from Benefit Chicago